Thesis Doc in Progress
Here it is--thus far.I have this saved as a PDF. How can I post a PDF? In this blog, all of my footnote are lost, unacceptable! and formating also dropped. Any advise?
It is, for the most part organized, though many notes to plug in and expound on.
Please feel free to comment and question.
...who's going to read this? its long...
Also--can anyone recommend a good ITP (or other) 'concept' thesis to read?
My 'mother molds' for heart and brain are ready to cast. My next step is to cast positives in wax. I'm afraid $$ will influence final choices...
i'm posting this link of my 'book' from last year--construction involved mold making. i will be using similar materials. for my physical 'object'. Maybe that will give some idea of the sort of things i make.
Thanks for reading.
As far as the laws of mathematics refer to reality, they are not certain, and as far as they are
certain, they do not refer to reality.
After a certain high level of technical skill is achieved, science and art tend to coalesce in esthetics, plasticity, and form. The greatest scientists are always artists as well.
Concern for man and his fate must always form the chief interest of all technical endeavors. Never forget this in the midst of your diagrams and equations.
All that is valuable in human society depends upon the opportunity for development accorded the individual.
He who can no longer pause to wonder and stand rapt in awe, is as good as dead; his eyes are closed.
The most beautiful thing we can experience is the mysterious. It is the source of all true art and science.
Albert Einstein
[THESIS STATEMENT]
Computing and technology are a powerful medium and vehicle now, and toward ‘future’. There will be no drawing back from this truth. My concern, my manifesto, if you will, is a proclamation that Art take a bold grasp on this medium, else a profound conduit to all that is essentially and uniquely human become anachronistic.
[PERSONAL STATEMENT]
[Intersect]
bisect, come together, converge, crisscross, cross, crosscut, cut, decussate, divide, intercross, join, meet, separate, touch, traverse
I considered opening my topic with this request: Please take a moment to try this exercise. Lets us all take 45 seconds to just breathe. With each out-breath count “one”. With any thought that arises, let it go. If you lose count, begin again at one. This is not a test. Do not close your eyes. The point is two-fold: to notice our brains are racing without intention and to not invest in any thoughts or ideas for 45 seconds.
Its an exercise I learned through a meditation practice.
I learned to meditate formally about 8 years ago. I was compelled to make a discipline of it during a time tumultuous for me. The practice was instrumental for me; it exposed my brain’s flood of thought. It allowed me ‘space’ between thoughts. Within that ‘space’ I was able see into my situation more creatively. This was a powerful new tool for me. At the same time, I recognized this experience of ‘space’ was very much the sense of space and fluidity I knew in encountering Art.
I believe Art is the best chronicle of the history of man. Art is a genuine expression—response to what it is to be human. “Man shows himself too in his relation to the surroundings, it his artifacts, and the expressive character of all the signs and marks he produces.” Man has made Art, his responsive mark, as long as we have record of man. Art is always a response, a personal, but also because man is social, natural social critique. Curators maybe the bishops of the record, but they are thoughtful. A walk though the Metropolitan Museum is a rich tour of man’s search for truth throughout time.
I have ‘learning disorders’ that require me to ‘translate’ what is ‘linear’ to most. There are typically gaps I have to fill to arrive at ‘addressed context’ in what in ‘virtual’. Piecing together, while it takes longer, exposes details not readily noticed once context is assigned. I have come to appreciate this ‘retarded’ process enough to employ it retrospectively when a context appears manipulative. As I see it, missing ‘what is immediate’ to many is my best intelligence, what is ’immediate’ is often a spoon-fed prescribed context.
Before coming to ITP, I had recently completed on independent study focusing on Design Psychology / An Exploration of Cognitive Experience in Built Environment. My primary interest in pursuing this study was to consider what choices in architecture influenced a person’s relationship to others in public buildings. Museums are excellent fodder for observation of this type of interaction.
In my career at ITP, I worked on a system that would deliver ‘organic’ population counts within a room so that ‘socially-sensitive output’ could be designed for that room. I had initially intended to address my the system for my thesis but ultimately decided portfolio form would be more appropriate, given there are many applicable scenarios that such a product could be used for.
[CONTEXT]
MANIFESTO
MAKE NEW-CONTEXT!
ALLOW NEW-CONTEXT!
My thesis explores the history cognitive science, the practice of taming modular cognition, and the function of art in society, and my theory that art must seize a place in technology else it may became a quaint thing of the past and an arcane interest of the eccentric and elite (is it not now?).
This is not a Luddite Hymn.
I say make art symbiotic with technology else we will find ourselves immune to a powerful instrument that that connects us to what is essentially and uniquely human.
There is something tongue-in-cheek about my choosing the term ‘manifesto’. I think it is appropriate for me to write here in the fashion, so have been reviewing samples for style. They vary, but all are emphatic and didactic. Mine will be to. It is a poetic license I will take.
Manifesto: It’s a strong word. And so are its synonyms:
acclamation, affidavit, allegation, announcement, article, attestation, bulletin, canon, charge, command, commandment, confirmation, constitution, credo, creed, decree, decretum, denunciation, deposition, dictate, dictum, directive, document, edict, enactment, gospel, fiat, injunction, instrument, judgment, law, mandate, notice, notification, order, ordinance, plea, precept, prescript, proclamation, profession, promulgation, pronouncement, pronunciamento, regulation, resolution, rule, ruling, statute, testament, testimony, ukase, ultimatumact, writ
Caveat emptor:
MANIFESTOS ARE RECKLESS!
Now--
Please bear with me. I love language. I want to make meaningful choices.
Here are some simple words I will be playing with them. I’d like to discus them. First print and define them.
con·text (k n t kst )
n.
1. The part of a text or statement that surrounds a particular word or passage and determines its meaning.
2. The circumstances in which an event occurs; a setting.
[Middle English, composition, from Latin contextus, from past participle of contexere, to join together : com-, com- + texere, to weave; see teks- in Indo-European Roots.]
2antibiotic
Function: noun
: a substance produced by or a semisynthetic substance derived from a microorganism and able in dilute solution to inhibit or kill another microorganism
1an·ti·bi·ot·ic
( -bI-'ät-ik; -bE-)
Function: adjective
1: tending to prevent, inhibit, or destroy life
2: of or relating to antibiotics or to antibiosis —an·ti·bi·ot·i·cal·ly /-i-k(&-)lE/ adverb
adj: of or relating to antibiotic drugs n: a chemical substance derivable from a mold or bacterium that kills microorganisms and cures infections; "when antibiotics were first discovered they were called wonder drugs”
sym·bi·o·sis (s m b - s s, -b -)
n. pl. sym·bi·o·ses (-s z)
1. Biology. A close, prolonged association between two or more different organisms of different species that may, but does not necessarily, benefit each member.
2. A relationship of mutual benefit or dependence.
[Greek sumbi sis, companionship, from sumbioun, to live together, from sumbios, living together: sun-, syn- + bios, life; see gwei- in Indo-European Roots.]
sym bi·ot ic (- t k) or sym bi·ot i·cal (- -k l) adj.
sym bi·ot i·cal·ly adv.
sym·bi·o·sis (s m b - s s, -b -)
n. pl. sym·bi·o·ses (-s z)
1. Biology. A close, prolonged association between two or more different organisms of different species that may, but does not necessarily, benefit each member.
2. A relationship of mutual benefit or dependence.
[Greek sumbi sis, companionship, from sumbioun, to live together, from sumbios, living together: sun-, syn- + bios, life; see gwei- in Indo-European Roots.]
sym bi·ot ic (- t k) or sym bi·ot i·cal (- -k l) adj.
sym bi·ot i·cal·ly adv.
Pease do read this crap! I mean to get down to small elements. There is purpose. These are tools.
re·act (r - kt )
v. re·act·ed, re·act·ing, re·acts
v. intr.
1. To act in response to or under the influence of a stimulus or prompting: reacted strongly to the sarcastic tone of the memorandum.
2. To act in opposition to a former condition or act: composers who reacted against romanticism.
3. To act reciprocally or in return.
4. Chemistry. To undergo a reaction: Methane reacts with hydroxyl to produce formaldehyde.
re·ac·tion (r - k sh n)
n.
1.
a. A response to a stimulus.
b. The state resulting from such a response.
2. A reverse or opposing action.
3.
a. A tendency to revert to a former state.
b. Opposition to progress or liberalism; extreme conservatism.
4. Chemistry. A change or transformation in which a substance decomposes, combines with other substances, or interchanges constituents with other substances.
5. Physics. A nuclear reaction.
6. Physics. An equal and opposite force exerted by a body against a force acting upon it.
7. The response of cells or tissues to an antigen, as in a test for immunization.
Main Entry: respond verb: answer
Synonyms: acknowledge, answer, answer back, behave, come back, come in, counter, feedback, feel for, have heart, have vibes, react, reciprocate, rejoin, reply, retort, return, talk back Antonyms: ask, ignore
Main Entry: react verb: respond Synonyms: acknowledge, act, answer, answer back, backfire, be affected, behave, boomerang, bounce back, conduct oneself, counter, echo, feel, feel for, function, give back, have vibes, operate, perform, proceed, rebound, reciprocate, recoil, recur, reply, return, revert, take, talk back, turn back, work
Subtle differences. Response v. Reaction
Do you play tennis? I play some, enough to know this: A skilled tennis player responds to the ball. She knows her skills and her racket. Her racket is an extension of her body. She is able to “see” the ball advance as if in slow motion, and she allows the ball to meet her racket as to place it where she wants it.
Without practice, you react. You see the ball exploding toward you, get the racket between you and wherever it seems to be coming from, —Swing! --and hope not to hit the net or outside the lines.
In thinking, listen, speaking, relating, believing, making, —Respond.
It may be an intention. A practice. An exercise.
Or one may encounter conditions and situations that inspire it. That is what I’m writing about.
trans·mit (tr ns-m t , tr nz-)
v. trans·mit·ted, trans·mit·ting, trans·mits
v. tr.
1. To send from one person, thing, or place to another; convey. See Synonyms at convey. See Synonyms at send1.
2. To cause to spread; pass on: transmit an infection.
3. To impart or convey to others by heredity or inheritance; hand down.
4. To pass along (news or information); communicate.
5.
a. Electronics. To send (a signal), as by wire or radio.
b. Physics. To cause (a disturbance) to propagate through a medium.
6. To convey (force or energy) from one part of a mechanism to another.
v. intr.
To send out a signal.
[Middle English transmitten, from Latin tr nsmittere : tr ns-, trans- + mittere, to send.]
trans·mit ta·ble adj.
re·ceive (r -s v )
v. re·ceived, re·ceiv·ing, re·ceives
v. tr.
1. To take or acquire (something given, offered, or transmitted); get.
2. To hear or see (information, for example): receive bad news; received a good report of the group's activities.
3. To have (a title, for example) bestowed on oneself.
4. To meet with; experience: receive sympathetic treatment.
5. To have inflicted or imposed on oneself: receive a penalty.
6. To bear the weight or force of; support: The beams receive the full weight of the walls and roof.
7. To take or intercept the impact of (a blow, for example).
8. To take in, hold, or contain: a tank that receives rainwater.
9. To admit: receive new members.
10. To greet or welcome: receive guests.
11. To perceive or acquire mentally: receive a bad impression.
12. To regard with approval or disapproval: essays that were received well.
13. To listen to and acknowledge formally and authoritatively: The judge received their oath of allegiance.
v. intr.
1. To acquire or get something; be a recipient.
2. To admit or welcome guests or visitors: The couple is not receiving this winter.
3. To partake of the Eucharist.
4. Electronics. To convert incoming electromagnetic waves into visible or audible signals.
5. Football. To catch or take possession of a kicked ball.
[Middle English receiven, from Old North French receivre, from Latin recipere: re-, re- + capere, to take; see kap- in Indo-European Roots.]
trans·duce (tr ns-d s , -dy s , tr nz-)
v. trans·duced, trans·duc·ing, trans·duc·es
1. To convert energy from one form to another.
2. To transfer genetic material or characteristics from one bacterial cell to another. Used of a bacteriophage or plasmid.
trans·duce
Pronunciation: tran(t)s-'d(y)üs, tranz-
Function: transitive verb
Inflected Forms: trans·duced; trans·duc·ing
1: to convert (as energy or a message) into another form
2: to cause (genetic material) to undergo transduction; also: to introduce genetic material into (a cell) by transduction
Transductor I bastardize. Its more poetic. I mean that which converts one form (of energy) to another.
History ‘Cognitive Science’------
Towards our new scientific view on the mind and object orientated phenomenon.
1951 Wilkes
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maurice_Vincent_Wilkes
In 1951, he developed the concept of microprogramming from the realization that the Central Processing Unit of a computer could be controlled by a miniature, highly specialized computer program in high-speed ROM. This concept greatly simplified CPU development. Microprogramming was first described at the Manchester University Computer Inaugural Conference in 1951, then published in expanded form in IEEE Spectrum in 1955. This concept was implemented in EDSAC 2, which also used multiple identical "bit slices" to simplify design. Interchangeable, replaceable tube assemblies were used for each bit of the processor. This was extremely advanced for the time.
Wilkes is also credited with the idea of symbolic labels, macros, and subroutine libraries. These are fundamental developments that made programming much easier and paved the way for high-level programming languages.
--and psychology
Christopher Longuet-Higgins 1973 Lighthill report,
Cognitive Science” coined in conference on AI
Cognition
--The intelligent processing of information.
The mental processes of an individual,
Beliefs,
Desires
And intentions
In the area of context awareness (i.e. abstraction or concretization), processes: knowledge, learning through experience.
The term "cognition" is also used in a wider sense to mean the act of knowing or knowledge, and may be interpreted in a social or cultural sense to describe the emergent development of knowledge and concepts within a group that culminate in both thought and action.
Heuristics: The tenets of behaviorism that essentially allows only connections between externally observable variables.
The study the structure of intelligent behavior.
Object Oriented Programming
IF THEN and FOR WHILE loops statement
Is all cognitive phenomenon governed by Object phenomenon Social Cognitive Reasoning?
Overheard in women’s bathroom:
“Its not like I want to marry him and have his children—I just want to fuck him!”
What is the meaning of this statement? (I’ve heard it before--)
Can resting on a map of a modular computational brain support what is essentially human? __ The Mind.
Essential to me is the exploration and practice toward “learning” that does not fit the computational rubric. Questioning though conscientiously not computing.
Do drop out of the IF-THEN Loop
Context Assignments Delivered from the Brain
What is ‘Modular Cognition’?-----
IF THEN logic
Your brain is a very busy organ!
We are mammals, animals, organisms, struggling to maintain existence in order to reproduce. (Yes, to produce, and to protect offspring so that they reproduce.
The 4 F’s
Feeding
Fighting
Fleeing
Making Love
All stimuli is processed, sorted and grade by these standards.
What you want to bring closer; get more of
What you want to repel.
Everything else is neutral; is ignored.
You have an organism to maintain. Its important.
Epigenesis
Knowledge - The remembering of things previously learned. This may involve the recall of a wide range of material, from specific facts to complete theories; involving all that is required in the bringing to mind of appropriate information. Knowledge represents the lowest level of learning outcomes in the cognitive domain. Objectives of lessons which will increase a student's knowledge can be stated with such behavioral terms as: arrange, cite, choose, check, define, describe, find, group, hold, identify, indicate, label, list, locate, match, memorize, name, narrate, observe, offer, omit, outline (stating a format), pick, point to, quote, recall, recite, recognize, record, relate, repeat, report, reproduce, say, select, show, sort, spell, state, tally, tell, touch, transfer, underline, and write. The next higher thinking skill is comprehension.
Cognitive - Having to do with the mental process or faculty of knowing, including such things as analysis, application, awareness, comprehension, perception, reasoning, synthesis, evaluation, and meta-cognition.
Analysis - The separation of the parts of a subject for individual study, in order to find out their nature, function, and meaning. Exercising the ability to break down learned material into its component parts so that its organizational structure may be understood.
analysis . description . interpretation . judgment . learning outcomes in the cognitive domain . understanding content and the structural form . identification
recognition . Objectives
Behavioral terms:
analyze. appraise . audit . break down . characterize . check . classify . compare
conclude (draw conclusions) . contrast . debate . deduce . determine . diagram
differentiate . discriminate . dissect . distinguish . examine . experiment generalize . graph . illustrate . inspect . infer . inventory . map . point out
outline (no format given) . question . reason . refute . relate to . research
screen . scrutinize . search . section . select . separate . sift . simplify . solve
study . subdivide . survey . syllogize . test . uncover
The next higher thinking skill is synthesis.
Synthesis - The forming of a new and coherent whole by combining separate parts, and the ability to do so. Or, the complex whole formed this way. Synthesis represents the fifth level of learning outcomes in the cognitive domain — the level of understanding just beyond application and analysis. Synthesis may involve the production of a unique communication (work of fine art, writing, or music), a plan of operations (research proposal), or set of abstract relations (scheme for classifying information). Learning outcomes in this area stress creative behaviors, with major emphasis on the formulation of new pattern or structures. Objectives of lessons which will increase a student's ability to synthesize can be stated with such behavioral terms as: assemble, blend, build, categorize, create, combine, compile, compose, construct, constitute, conceive, deconstruct, design, develop, devise, effect, evolve, explain, form, formulate, generate, invent, make up, model, modify, originate, plan, produce, rearrange, reconstruct, reorder, reorganize, revise, rewrite, structure, summarize, tell, and transform. The next higher thinking skill is evaluation. Also see Bloom's Taxonomy, fusion, incongruity, interdisciplinary, original, simulation, syncretism, synergy, transformation, unity, and universal artwork.
What is essentially human?
Emotional growth though love, pain, compassion, change, loss, and the awareness of mortality.
On personal Time: quotes from Eric Fromm (1950’s)
The Sane Society
Erich Fromm writes of the tendency to avoid what is essentially human.
Look at Nighthawks at the Dinner Edward Hopper (date)
Critic on viewer’s relationship to the painting
An old man working at a simple job.
A couple. Lovers?
The lone man with his back facing us?
Nighthawks at the Dinner is a painting most all of us know. Its simple, but important. To me, it is an important example of “non-linear narrative”. (Why? I’ll write more later—think about it and tell me if you want.)
Sanity = adjustment to social conditions w/o regard to what is essentially human. (Basic meaning)
Infant development—epigenous mind continuum…(p14)
P18. Conditions-Infinite malleability to poor conditions—reaction [Fromm]
Consider symbolic representations of the mind: a uniquely human idea and seat of emotional growth.
The Wizard of Oz Frank Baum
The Tin Woodsman Story
Have you ever read L. Frank Baum’s The Wizard of Oz? We all have seen the movie? In reading the novel, I found throughout that the choices made to dramatize in the screenplay were correct. Even the choice to omit what I feel is the most profound narrative: if the Tin Woodsman’s story had been included in the movie, it would have been Tin Woodsman’s quest rather than Dorothy’s we would all recall.
(Short notes on the tin woodsman tale—(later)
"No, my head is quite empty," answered the Woodman. "But once I had brains, and a heart also; so, having tried them both, I should much rather have a heart."
"All the same," said the Scarecrow, "I shall ask for brains instead of a heart; for a fool would not know what to do with a heart if he had one."
"I shall take the heart," returned the Tin Woodman; "for brains do not make one happy, and happiness is the best thing in the world."
Blah blah-- discuss
Notebook sketch for ‘object’ -
Why does Art matter?
Art addresses that that is essentially human by offering a private opening to the mind – the brain’s heart.
Art invites and allows New Context:
Art provokes communication with the essential self.
Robert Rauschenberg on the gap between art and life. All art exists in the gap between physical object and human experience. That gap has a lot of room in it to play, and the result is changing games, styles, and interpretations. Art's leap of the imagination outraces even the promise of human flight. With Fountain or a stepladder, it can become hypothetical.
(The mind may be something of a curse. That humans make art is something of a miracle.)
Why must Art embrace computing and technology?
Because modular computation claims a cognitive mapping that mirrors the human cognitive process, and because in many ways, our intellectual processing does closely match the paradigm of object orientated computing, we risk being seduced by a reductive logic.
The reductive, if epistemic logic of modular computation fosters both simplified and flawed rapid sorting of stimuli, and weakens our social contract by inspiring addiction to mediated interaction experience.
Computing and technology are pivotal and inspiring tools.
Art is a fundamental and vital tool.
Art must utilize computing and technology to remain contemporary and also in order to balance that medium’s ‘task’ orientated, one-to-one correlation effect in our lives.
Art that embraces technology and computing is neither frivolous nor profane, but is an integral and contemporary ‘product’ that promotes emotional growth and enriches human experience.
Art is a rescue line to man. It can save us from a whirling sea of reactions and connects us to ‘all men’ throughout time.
[See--note chapter 72 ‘The Monkey Rope’ Moby Dick]
http://www.princeton.edu/~batke/moby/moby_072.html
We are now, and will more and more be inundated with trite and commercial context assignments.
We are now, and will more and more be inundated with ‘mediated experience’. How will this influence our sensitivity to actual human-interface experience?
This is an exploration and a plea.
It is a call-out to artists and designers to make conscious and conscientious choices in their work.
It is a call-out to artists and designers to resist the temptation to entertain and to risk challenging.
It is a call-out to artist and designers to harness technology and to subvert the path of least resistance: the paradigm of modular cognition, by producing work that also owns progress.
It is a call-out to all to take care of the mind as one does the body-- to engage the brain’s heart, and to support that in others.
What Is Mediated Experience?
Experience By Proxy
Can porn teach you to make love? I am not interested in morals or morality, per se. --Love it. But it’s not real. Not essential.
IM
VR
T.V.
Porn
MySpace
Block-busters
What is the difference in ‘whacking oneself off’ and making love?
Connection to another person. Risk?
--Do suspended disbelief and identification with characters on screen replace personal intimacy?
--Do we recognize more faces of (object) celebrities than the individuals we encounter daily? (And have some shared-awareness of their lives?)
Add crap from notes----
Is interest in verisimilitude is greater then interest is real?
Porn
as if
sex
You have a body.
Porn = easy, access, hot, safe from disease-- (no heartache)
It is a proxy for what is sex--- making love.
I know a woman who, as a child, believed her family had visited the Grand Canyon, but it turns out, it was the Brady Bunch family that drove out West, Bobby and Cindy who got lost.
Everything you believe is “true” to you.
(Epigenesis) learning
practice
Blink Malcolm Galdwell
‘Blink’
Problems w/ blink
The rope incident--
Taming Modular Cognition
Experience does not equal joy or success. Experience is awareness. Not of self. It is fluidity beyond self, a sense of wholeness and connectedness.
Encountering Art inspirers a moment to quiet rapid cognition, to give the busy brain mind-space, and the opportunity to appreciate new context.
Context Assignments Manufactured by Technology
“Art I= ‘what the fuck!’”
“Design = ‘Ahhhhh”
Commercial design ++
Assigned context----ahhhhhh
If the mind is flexible and constantly develops through experience (epigenesis); if we do not interact with people as objects, are we in training to through the quality/ reality of our interactions?
What Is New-Context?------
The Function of Art in Society
Epigenesis is the Transductor.
There are symbols and gestures: give them space. There are assumptions, but no rules really. Check your experience. How might that history have been the product of exponential seduction and reaction? You can have a find your own context.
Bucket water wax: pouring back and forth until empty
(Language of new Media Lev Manovitch 1995)
Ellipses in narration
Missing details
“Representational short-cuts that require the user to fill in information”
New cognitive demands on viewer to bridge the gap between unrelated images”
(owning the narrative?)--constructivists
“semi-abstraction”
p. 57 “ When we use the concept of “interactive media” exclusively in relation to computer-based media, there is the danger that we will interpret “interaction” literally, equating it with physical interaction between user and a media object (pressing a button, choosing a link, moving the body), at the expense of psychological interaction.
N85.A65c.1
Stodard, Irwin Edman, Bruno Bettelheim
Art as the Measure of Man
1964
Museum of modern art
Universality of “art”
p17
---Constant search for truth, beauty and humanity—sufficient for peace—peace of mind.
Art: Illusion; The transformation of what the sense organs bring us and the brain electronically integrates---greater reality than immediate psychological sensation.
Art will not be funded--
Art is dangerous--
What better exposes cowardice, cruelty, and lust for power?
As opposed to design—political art, advertising
“ Likely to proclaim untruth as truth, a tyrant as friend of the people and ugly social situation as gift from heaven.”
Peter Fingesten the art journal, fall, 1961, XXI, 1
(Modrian believed in theosophy and mediation
Kandinsky –intuition inner spiritual forces
Zen Buddhism
On faith: Fingesten says (1961) our faith is now “the ultimate decency of human kind and our ability to preserve it through social forces
2006 what is our American faith? Is it the ultimate power of consumption, freedom to consume and ability to enforce it though economic power and war?
Parts recombined to new wholes
Art--
Observation: interpretation; response
What is known, what is believed, what is rejected, what is dreamed and prayer for, what there are no sensible words for: a desire for total communication. (dt)
--Art does not “teach” at all in a literal sense. It presents a vivid reminder of sensuous qualities available to us
It obliquely and indirectly teaches us to remember what in our habitation to formality and logic we have forgotten…
Art is an education in and of the senses. Sense of form and education of our emotions (Irwin Edman)
“Science, with its handmaiden, technology’s essential as a shield against hunger, disease, slavery and superstition, and a structural form of human progress. Art on the other hand, is essential if we are to keep above the other animals and in control of the animal drives within us.” –the 4 F's)
Art as Expression Dewey 1934,1958
“Expression strikes below the barriers that separate beings from one another.”
“Every intense experience of friendship completes itself artistically”
“Art also renders men aware of their union with one another in origin and destiny (pp270-71)
--Art is an honest record of history, documented without political regard or agenda.
It more often upsets then placates. In is fiercely honest as the artist means to express at that moment. It can be destroyed but not revoked. It is not produced for gain or advertisement. ----art = ‘what the fuck?!: design = Ahhhh…(Theresa quote) look at communist propaganda. Norman Rockwell (building an identity of a white AMERICAN middle class (new and brief/post WWII == propaganda)
Re read “letter” to Red
Reread intro essay
Symbol—rules
Outside symbol’s rules and no-symbols---is no—symbol a symbol? No
Some –most will fail to communicate on a “universal” scale. The effort and effort of appreciation much continue as an exercise. Find the intended(?) meaning—best intention most probably (personal) honesty.
Iconology/image, text, ideology
W.J.T. Mitchell
University or Chicago press 1986
Read more on Marxism/ Hegel
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Merton
Art as Art
Ad Reinhardt
Explores another context: Islamic decoration, Chinese landscape: makes The Black Paintings
The social role of art?
Eschatological (Greek—eskhatos “last”
Barbara Rose on Art as Art
Intro: p xvii
“Reinhart viewed art as the essential manifestation of human freedom.”
“Not through permissiveness and subjectivity but through discipline.”
(What is essentially human)
“The liberation from the self and the shifting flux of the everyday world.” (away from the 4 F’s)
Art must make--
“a withdrawal from commerce” |art “can only endure as “spiritual” “moral” worth”
Go back to (Mexican) –Art for Art’s Sake (Manifesto 1922)
“Abstract art is always rational, human and self-conscious.”
Aesthetic principles: Absolute, timeless and meaningless == no “worldly” relevance. —What is “worldly?
Painting is solitary.
Pictures are public
Art for Art's Sake (Mexican manifesto)
See Kant
Publish their views, their aims, their tendencies, and meet this nursery tale of the specter of communism with a manifesto of the party itself.
Huh??
Ad Reinhardt. “The one assault on five art is the ceaseless attempt to sub-serve it to some other end or value”
Value? Is for its empty “”mindless” “meaningless”= un-prescribed idea. Hold fast to NO idea. No idea is best idea. Best lens.
Edgar Allan Poe
"Were I called on to define, very briefly, the term Art, I should call it 'the reproduction of what the Senses perceive in Nature through the veil of the soul.' The mere imitation, however accurate, of what is in Nature, entitles no man to the sacred name of 'Artist.'"
(1809-1845), U.S. poet, critic, short-story writer. "Marginalia," in Southern Literary Messenger (Richmond, VA, June 1849; reprinted in Essays and Reviews, 1984).
[Polemic? The art or practice of inciting disputation or causing controversy, for example in religious, philosophical, or political matters. As such a polemic text on a topic is written specifically to dispute or refute a topic that is widely viewed to be a "sacred cow" or beyond reproach, in an effort to "stir up trouble".]
"Paradoxically though it may seem, it is none the less true that life imitates art far more than art imitates life."
Oscar Wilde.
"But all categories of art, idealistic or realistic, surrealistic or constructivist (a new form of idealism) must satisfy a simple test (or they are in no sense works of art): they must persist as objects of contemplation."
Herbert Read (1893-1968), British art writer. Modern Sculpture.
"Art establishes the basic human truths which must serve as the touchstone of our judgment."
John F. Kennedy (1917-1963) U.S. president. An address at Amherst College, October 26, 1963.
"Art today is a new kind of instrument, an instrument for modifying consciousness and organizing new modes of sensibility ... Artists have had to become self-conscious aestheticians: continually challenging their means, their materials and methods."
Susan Sontag (1933-), American writer. Against Interpretation.
"Do not imagine that Art is something which is designed to give gentle uplift and self-confidence. Art is not a brassiere. At least, not in the English sense. But do not forget that brassiere is the French word for life-jacket."
Julian Barnes (1946-), English writer. Flaubert's Parrot.
"For me art shouldn't be a fixed idea that I have before I start making it. I want it to include all the fragility and doubt that I go through the day with. Sometimes I'll take a walk just to forget whatever good idea I had that day because I like to go into the studio not having any ideas. I want the insecurity of not knowing, like performers feel before a performance. Everything I can remember, and everything I know, I have probably already done, or somebody else has."
Robert Rauschenburg (1925-), American artist, quoted by Michael Kimmelman in an article about Rauschenburg, New York Times, Arts & Leisure section 2, August 27, 2000, p. 26.
Bloom's Taxonomy - A hierarchical list of thinking skills. The six levels of Bloom's taxonomy should be used in stating objectives of lessons and in devising questions which stimulate thinking at each level. The six levels, from lowest to highest, are: knowledge, comprehension, application, analysis, synthesis, and evaluation. Another level, some propose, is meta-cognition. Also see cognitive, effort, interdisciplinary, and multiple intelligence theory.
Syncretism - The merging or fusion of differing philosophies, as in opposing art movement, especially when the result is either incomplete or incongruous. Also see synergy, synthesis, transformation, and universal artwork.
NO-! --Meta-cognition or metacognition - The ability to think with discernment about what one is thinking. Some propose that meta-cognition represents the seventh and highest level of learning outcomes in the cognitive domain — the level of understanding just beyond synthesis and evaluation. Also see Bloom's Taxonomy and theory.
Bloom gives us a loop! NO! -- evaluation - The ability to judge the value of material (work of art, statement, writing, music, etc.) for a given purpose. Evaluation represents the sixth level of learning outcomes in the cognitive domain — the level of understanding just beyond analysis and synthesis. Intelligent judgments must be based upon definite criteria. These may be internal (organization) or external criteria (relevant to the purpose) and the student may determine the criteria or be given them. Objectives of lessons which will increase a student's ability to evaluate can be stated with such behavioral terms as: accept, adjudge, appraise, arbitrate, assay, assess, award, classify, conclude, criticize, critique, decide, decree, describe, determine, discriminate, estimate, evaluate, explain, grade, interpret, judge, justify, measure, predict, prioritize, rank, rate, referee, reject, rule on, select, settle, summarize, support, umpire, and weigh. Some have proposed that there is one higher thinking skill: meta-cognition. Also see achievement, assessment, Bloom's Taxonomy, description, effort, and interesting.
Pale award---
achieve, achievement - To achieve is to accomplish; to perform with success: to attain with effort or despite difficulty. Achievement is either the act of accomplishing or the thing accomplished. Achievement is especially the successful performance that reaches or exceeds a standard level.
A distinction between effort and achievement is noteworthy: effort is trying which may or may not result in success, while achievement is effort resulting in success. In other words, effort is of tremendous importance, but unless (or until) effort results in meeting goals, it does not met the criterion of "achievement." In an educational setting, the goals of assignments are set by educators (as part of a larger community) to be observable objectives. In a graphic design environment, goals may be tied to sets of clients' specifications. In the fine arts, artists' achievements may be gauged by gallery sales and the judgments of viewers (especially of art critics, art historians, museums, and posterity). In each of these and in all art arenas, as in life's endeavors of every kind, the most fundamental gauge of achievement is ultimately one's measure of personal satisfaction.
The reception of praise, awards, or cash payments should not be confused with achievements (unless those have been the principal motivating factors, which would tend to devalue them), although these things recognize achievements. Renown, whether fame or notoriety, is another indicator of achievement, potentially both helpful and problematic. Historically, the works for which artists first become famous, have persistently influenced how later works are received. So, although renown may be achieved, what you wish to be renowned for is more worthy of your attention than the striving for renowned itself. Vandals and forgers may become famous, after all, but are those reputations anyone needs?
In heraldry, a coat of arms is sometimes called a "complete achievement."
Art is not beautiful!
Princeton thinks ART IS DESIGN
http://www.princeton.edu/artofscience/guidelines.html
http://mitpress2.mit.edu/e-journals/Leonardo/isast/articles/shanken.html
Technology and Intuition: A Love Story? Roy Ascott's Telematic Embrace
Edward A. Shanken
Department of Art & Art History
Duke University
Box 90754 Durham, NC 27708, U.S.A.
As the demands of an evolving military-industrial-media- information complex for technology push intuition to its limits -- not in the pursuit of any human ideal -- but in the interests of self-preservation and power, the issue of human values still remains. Which ones are worth keeping? What other types of values may emerge? What role will visual information (and its corollaries in textual and other systems of envisioning) indeed, art, and the ability to comprehend it -- play in the future? Unraveling Ascott's polemical query, "Is there love in the telematic embrace?" reveals the further questions, "What will love be?" "How will it be constructed?" "By whom?" and "For whom?"
The creation and expansion of a global consciousness is an admirable aspiration, and may serve to generate greater empathy, but no amount of consciousness can result in planetary harmony unless the physical conditions of human life are vastly improved. The readers of this text may enjoy a higher level of interaction with geographically remote colleagues than ever before, but on a global scale, it would appear that emerging technologies exacerbate social segmentation rather than bring people closer together. While we use and become absorbed into emerging technologies, and technological modes of being, we continually distance ourselves as a privileged elite from the 80% of the world that does not have telephones, much less an institutionally supported internet link. Moreover, Kristine Stiles has suggested that the international intelligence community now has the educated classes right where they want us -- at home, in our computerized cottage industries where our behavior can be most easily monitored. In this light, it is doubtful that telematics or any technology will enable the radical reorganization and unification of global society in the near future.
Ascott resists the inevitability of such sober prophecies. He summonses the social force of art against technology. ---I call artist designers, programmers, etc
Ascott consider the artist's behavior to be properly considered art, but he expanded the province of art to include idea, ritual, and system -- important additional constituents of consciousness
For Ascott, art became a participatory process (as opposed to a discrete object or event) defined not by formal parameters, but by behavioral relationships in which artist, observer, and environment (including global telematic networks) are all integrated in an emergent, interactive system of morphological relationships.
. Creative Evolution, written in 1907 by French philosopher Henri Bergson, is paramount among these sources [12]. Bergson argued that as scientific reason enables the accumulation of knowledge about physical matter, so metaphysical intuition enables the knowledge of spirit. He theorized that the union of reason and intuition (what he called duration) conjoins past, present, and future, dissolving the diachronic appearance of categorical time, and providing a unified experience (or conscious awareness) of the synchronic relatedness of continuous change.
--Ascott clearly attaching to “universal imagery and systems.
I am wore thinking of individual response to common stimuli--
His Transactional Set (1971) was comprised of standard forms (rings, clothes pins, a funnel) set on a grid-like table. The composition could be continuously altered and interpreted, like changing hexagrams of the I Ching, by viewers-participants. Over a decade before the I Ching could be accessed over the Internet, Ascott had participants at their computer terminals around the world toss coins for the first planetary throw of the I Ching [14]. Ascott also has drawn on such sources as Navajo sand painting, Druid rock formations, and parapsychology as models of spiritual and cosmological systems that he incorporates in his work.
Main Entry: in·tu·ition
Pronunciation: "in-t(y)u-'ish-&n
Function: noun
1: immediate apprehension or cognition without reasoning or inferring
2: knowledge or conviction gained by intuition
3: the power or faculty of gaining direct knowledge or cognition without evident rational thought and inference —in·tu·it /in-'t(y)ü-&t/ transitive verb —in·tu·ition·al /"in-t(y)u-'ish-n&l, -&n-&l/ adjective —in·tu·itive /in-'t(y)ü-&t-iv/ adjective —in·tu·itive·ly adverb
Blink: the rope example
http://mitpress2.mit.edu/e-journals/Leonardo/isast/articles/shanken.html
----I have chosen to focus on his article "Is There Love in the Telematic Embrace?" (1990) For its richly provocative description of how the marriage of technology and intuition in telematic systems might enable the systemic extension of human perception and the unified planetary expansion of consciousness. In this essay, he writes, "[N]etworking provides the very infrastructure for spiritual interchange that could lead to the harmonization and creative development of the whole planet"
read? The Tipping Point, Malcolm Gladwell
Such a spiritual interchange leading to planetary harmony is, for Ascott, the result of love, and the statement above demonstrates the artist's faith in technology to embody and cultivate it. The transformation he proposes is akin to the ideas of global consciousness expounded by French paleontologist and theologian Teilhard de Chardin, who theorized the "noosphere" and by futurologist Peter Russell, who theorized the "global brain." Ideas like these were invaluable to Ascott in his quest to imagine a parallel development through the visual languages of art. Though the noosphere and the global brain as theoretical constructs are rationally problematic, in the following pages I consider the implications of Ascott's application of such metaphysical theories to art.
My interest: individual consciousness.
Holy-fuck!
Peter Russell builds on Teilhard's notion of noosphere in his theses on the "global brain." Writing in 1982, Russell claimed that, based on the trend of data- processing capacity doubling every two and a half years, by the year 2000, the global telecommunications network could equal the complexity of the human brain. He theorized that this global brain (the neurons of which would be comprised of individuals, all telematically interconnected, like a neural network) could give rise to an emergent form of consciousness [21]. According to Russell, this structural system, modeled on that of biological organisms, provided the essential prerequisites for a new evolutionary level, the emergence of a cyborgian superorganism integrating technology and intuition.
(Better--) Again, as with Teilhard, Russell's theory of the global brain is troublingly romantic. He uncritically draws parallels between the brain and global telecommunications systems without rigorously questioning the material and functional dissimilarity between these two systems. While the research of neuroscientists and philosophers such as Patricia Churchland and Owen Flanagan suggest that consciousness may be understood in terms of a materialist explanation, it is equally apparent that consciousness does not occur simply as a result of a high level of complexity.
--resolve--
As a cultural system established simultaneously adjacent to and apart from other disciplinary conventions, art often makes use of systems of thought unacceptable anywhere else and at odds with convention. Art, for Ascott, functions as both theory and practice, and simultaneous as neither, as an entity unto itself drawing on the theory and practice of other disciplines for its own ends. These ends function in the realm of consciousness, in the transformation of belief, and in the modification of behavior. The import of Ascott's theoretical writings and telematic projects lies not in their technical achievement, nor in their practical application as a means to attain their theorized aspirations, but rather, I believe, in their conceptualization and transmission of alternative realities, artistic models for the future.
--respond—in trouble shooting, start w/ the most simple:
--and keep your model in “near” space—
As art, Ascott's inquiry into the telematic future inhabits an ambiguous zone of inquiry. He proposes his interactive telematic projects as working models of unified cybernetic systems (such as the noosphere and the global brain), in which participants at remote locations around the globe collaborate in the interactive creation and simultaneous experience of the work in real time. For example, Aspects of Gaia, presented at the 1989 Ars Electronica festival in Linz, Austria, explored various facets of the earth -- Gaia -- seen from "a multiplicity of spiritual, scientific, cultural, and mythological perspectives" [22]. Participants, telematically connected around the world, collaborated in the creation and transformation of texts, images, and artificial- life forms related to this idea. Ascott conceives of this work as behavioral and interactive, constantly in a state of becoming, where distinctions between artist, viewer, and artwork are blurred, and where artist, viewer, and artwork, technology and intuition, are potentially united in the unfolding duration of their harmoniously negotiated mutual creation, or global consciousness.
But participants may not experience an expanded form of consciousness on the level of the noosphere, nor have telematic projects reached the computational complexity of a global brain, yet. Moreover, there are no hard data to prove the expansion of neural activity in the brains of participants, nor has the electromagnetic radiation given off by the theorized global field of consciousness been quantified.
Ascott's utopianism is the result of the positive spirit of an artist whose creative mission is to formulate constructive visions of the future as an inspiration for change. He maintains that artists and designers can contribute to shaping the emerging future by creatively envisioning its many possibilities. In this sense, Ascott's praxis bears a striking affinity to what art historian Kristine Stiles describes as "the strategic convictions of avant-garde artists throughout history: the perception, conception, envisioning and representation of alternative realities and systems of meaning" [24]. I contend that it is in this spirit of avant-garde art that Ascott's theory and practice can most usefully and thoughtfully be considered.
Brain behind reverse glass?
An intimate bond can never really be consummated with such hyaline partners because they are pathologically unable to absorb love, but can only reflect it, or let it pass through their transparent voids. Rather than enabling a condition of mutual giving, the reflective glass surfaces transform communication into monologue, passionate attraction into onanism.
Add camera—projection
Should more than single user be possible?
Go to Myspace? make "profile"?
It is a constant reminder that the telematic participant is inevitably a perpetual observer, a voyeur whose electronic relationships are autoerotic soliloquies in a pornographic global mirror.
In "Is There Love in the Telematic Embrace?" Ascott attempted to attribute to electronic art the potential to embody love. His aim was to address technophobia in general, and in particular to answer critics of electronic art who feared that technology would overwhelm and dehumanize the arts, a last bastion of humanist values. If it could be shown that telematic art had the potential to embody love, then art could be electronic and serve humanist principles simultaneously. In constructing his argument Ascott strategically opposed seemingly incompatible ontologies. His Fourieran description of love as passionate attraction implied a universal, transcendental principle in dynamic interplay with the apparent contingencies of love regarding history, gender, and culture, and between love manifested in physical presence as opposed to telepresence. While maintaining an ostensibly unconditional principle of love and promoting collaborative emergence, Ascott characterizes his project in Derridean terms as "pure electronic difference" -- one rife with "uncertainty" and "instability" [28]. Indeed, the artist's resistance to conform to either an 'Enlightenment' or a Postmodern ontology is a particularly provocative aspect of his work. His insistence on maintaining paradox, on permitting and encouraging the simultaneous coexistence of logically incompatible systems is, I believe, one of his important achievements. Such a strategy is consistent with his desire to merge technology and intuition, reason and metaphysics, and belongs to the tradition of artistic visionaries able to imagine the ways in which the confluence of philosophical rationalism, science, and the metaphysical aspects of aesthetic theory offer complementary structures for the construction of alternate systems of meaning.
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derrida)


